New Rule: Any professor who thinks tenure should be scrapped must give up theirs first.

25 07 2010

Ilya Somin at the Volokh Conspiracy:

One of the interesting aspects of the tenure system is that even many of its principal beneficiaries — tenured professors — agree that it is a severely flawed institution that should be scrapped.

Really? All I see are the same bunch of conservative gadflies making the same argument over and over again but never putting their money where their mouth is.

I always though it would be a cold day in hell when I agreed with Tyler Cowen about anything, but I certainly agree with this:

Traditionally I’ve been sympathetic to tenure (disclaimer: I have it), in part because the schools which have done away with it — the for-profits — have carved out a big niche but they have not displaced traditional non-profit, tenure-driven higher education in most fields. Few parents dream of sending their kids there. My point today is simply to note that tenure critics have yet to spell out what the alternative — and thus the debate — really looks like.

Somin responds to Cowen’s argument this way:

Tyler also makes the reasonable point that before we abolish tenure, we need to think carefully about what the alternative system would look like. There may not be any one system that would be best for all institutions. Competition and experimentation could lead to useful innovations.

It could also lead to hundreds, if not thousands of people ending up taking huge pay cuts or even jobless. That’s why I’m waiting for every professor who wants to abolish tenure to put their head on the chopping block first.

I expect to be waiting for a very long time.



2 responses

29 07 2010
Anyone who uses this concept from now on must send me five cents. « More or Less Bunk

[…] who uses this concept from now on must send me five cents. 29 07 2010 If I define a rule that proves particularly useful, I demand the right to name it after myself. So here is Rees’ […]

30 07 2010
The Tenure Debate, Again: You First. No, You First. « Post Academic

[…] Roberts on July 30, 2010 Tags: academic jobs, job skills, post academic jobs, tenure, the academy More or Less Bunk took a page from Bill Maher and set a New Rule: “Any professor who thinks tenure should be […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: